Al Qaeda's Surprising Origins
Ethnic rivalries in Saudi Arabia may have as much to do with 9/11 as hatred of the U.S.
March / April 2004
Leif Utne Utne magazine
We thought we had it down -- a virulent form of Islamic
fundamentalism called Wahhabism, heavily supported by the ruling
elite of Saudi Arabia, is the ideology of al Qaeda. If it weren't
for the influence of extremist Wahhabi clerics on the young minds
of 15 of the 9/11 hijackers who came from Saudi Arabia (out of 19
total), the Twin Towers might still be standing. Right?
RELATED CONTENT
Re: Secret Strategy to Win the White House...
The Prime Time Smearing of Sami Al Arian January 30, 2002 Issue By Sara V. Buckwitz The Prime Time...
Al Qaeda Ate My Student Loans January 7, 2002 Issue By Sara V. Buckwitz Al Qaeda Ate My Student Lo...
The best-selling comic on great news sources and his favorite liars...
Not so fast. Like most stories of international political
intrigue, it's not that simple. It turns out that Osama bin
Laden and a majority of the 15 Saudi hijackers were members
of a persecuted minority within Saudi Arabia, the Asiris, with
close ties to Yemen and a deep hatred of the Wahhabi establishment,
reports John R. Bradley in the British political and cultural
magazine Prospect (Sept. 2003).
Tribal and regional loyalties have always been stronger than
national identity in Saudi Arabia. After all, the Saudi kingdom is
not even 80 years old. King Abdul Aziz Ibn Saud cobbled the country
together largely by paying off tribal sheikhs and marrying off his
daughters. Since that time, the al-Saud family has maintained its
weak hold on power through an elaborate patronage system and an
oil-for-security pact signed with the United States in 1945. Rising
population and falling oil prices have put serious economic
pressures on that system in recent years, testing regional leaders'
allegiance.
And the Asiris, perhaps more than any other regional group, have
long resented the Saudi rulers, who are Bedouin tribesmen from the
al-Najd region to the north. A mountainous region in the south,
Asir was originally part of Yemen and was for centuries a Sufi
theocracy with dreams of redeeming Islam. 'Most people of Asir know
by heart a particular Hadith, or saying of the Prophet, to
the effect that the final triumph of Islam will be brought about by
the people of southern Arabia,' Bradley writes.
The House of Saud's weakening grip on power, coupled with a
history of tribal rivalries and ill treatment of the Asiris, has
made the region a natural recruiting ground for Osama bin Laden. As
Bradley puts it: 'Not only because he shares their Yemeni-Saudi
tribal roots, but also because, again like him, they resent being
ruled by a clan which, they believe, does not enforce its Islamic
authority with sufficient rigor and, in many cases, lives by double
standards. By attacking the U.S. guarantors of Saudi security and
survival, these tribal Saudis were targeting the historic
Saudi-Wahhabi alliance.'