The Brain on the Couch
Some therapists are introducing their clients to a new tool: brain science
September / October 2004
Craig Cox Utne magazine
Daniel Siegel is using his brain a lot more these days. But it's
not the one in his skull that's got him so excited; it's the
plastic one in his office.
RELATED ARTICLES
High Country News... Fishwrap... Russian Life... Last Child in the Woods... The Beat Within... Para...
Why gluttony is a grrl thing...
In a Family Way Two guys, two unruly kids, and a lesson in hilarious love January February 2003 By...
LSD studies that could open the door to a new age...
The associate professor of psychiatry at UCLA and author of
The Developing Mind (Guilford Press, 1999) is one of a new
wave of psychotherapists who are discovering the power of
neuro-biology in their everyday counseling work. 'I not only have a
model of the brain that I . . . take out maybe three or four times
a week with different patients, but I also have a chalkboard I
constantly use to draw brain diagrams to help people see their
problems in a different light,' Siegel tells Mary Sykes Wylie and
Richard Simon in Psychotherapy Networker
(March/April 2004).
The results, he says, have been eye-opening. 'Patients keep
telling me things like, 'You know last week when you drew that
picture of the brain? I finally understood my amygdala. It's
changed my whole view of what's been going on with me all these
years.''
Siegel and others are looking at new ways to read brain activity
and apply that information to psychotherapy. Their recent embrace
of neuroscience, argue Wylie and Simon, represents a fundamental
shift in a profession that historically has been at odds with
neuroscience and its tendency to see an individual's temperament
and psychological health as ruled by genetics and seldom subject to
change. But as scientists have learned more about the brain's
innate 'plasticity,' psychotherapists have become more willing to
use that knowledge to help their clients.
Contrary to earlier thinking, researchers now know that the
brain produces new cells throughout a person's life and that its
development is influenced by experience as well as genetics. Each
stimulus we experience causes millions of neurons to fire together
in the brain, creating neural maps or networks that add up to what
Wylie and Simon call 'the architecture of all our experiences.'
This new knowledge of the brain, combined with advances in
technology to measure and interpret brain activity, have allowed
therapists and their clients to consider how an individual's brain
functions in a way that goes well beyond the word-bound techniques
of traditional 'talking cure' therapy.
'Magnetic resonance imaging (MRI), positron emission tomography
(PET), and CAT scans can now photo-graph the brain at work and play
and even after therapy,' Wylie and Simon note. 'With electron
microscopes, the nuclear tagging of living human molecules, and
other biochemical investigative techniques, scientists can now see
what happens in different parts of the brain when an alcoholic
looks at a martini, or a schizophrenic has a hallucination, or a
meditator experiences spiritual transcendence.'
This allows the therapist and the client to look at problems in
a more focused, less emotional way. As psychologist Marcia Stern,
author of Child-Friendly Therapy (Norton, 2002), puts it,
clients experience the workings of their brain in a much more
personal way than they experience even their own behavior patterns.
Showing them how their brain processes information, for instance,
gives them 'an incredibly compelling way of grasping the most
intimate details of their moment-to-moment functioning,' she says.
It helps them 'understand their own behavior and the behavior of
other people in their families in a new way -- for example, how
easily our thinking brains can become hijacked by our feeling
brains -- while dramatically diminishing the amount of shame and
blame that gets passed around.'