Who Owns the Forest?
A land crisis in a remote region of Nicaragua results in violence, ethnic strife, and victims on both sides
October 14, 2004
Anthony Vaccaro InTheFray
The Mayangna are desperate. As Nicaragua's oldest indigenous tribe,
they have long been considered the caretakers of the Nicaraguan
rain forest, upon which they rely for housing and hunting. They
have been trying to peacefully resist the migration of Mestizo
farmers onto their land for fifty years. Last February, the
Miskitu, another indigenous tribe being displaced by the same
landless farmers, burned down a Mestizo settlement in February,
leaving three dead. Those familiar with the situation anticipate
the Mayanga taking a similarly violent route. 'We want to kick them
out peacefully,' says Emilio Fendley, a member of the Mayangna
community. 'But we can't; they won't go.'The landless Mestizo
farmers are also desperate. While it's easy to demonize them for
taking Mayangna land and employing slash-and-burn agriculture, they
see little alternative. With no political clout, no money, and
little education, the landless farmers simply want somewhere to
settle down. 'Our lands [on the Pacific side of Nicaragua] have all
dried up, and we need to feed ourselves. If they don't want us
here, then just tell us where we should go.'The Nicaraguan
government did pass a law forbidding the outside settlement of
indigenous lands, but it has provided no resources to local
authorities to enforce the law and has otherwise been indifferent
to the conflict. And those local authorities, while annoyed by the
presence of the Mestizos, are reluctant to get involved in the
first place. As one official puts it: 'They're not from here, so
they are not our problem.'As a result of this neglect, the
Mestizo's and Mayangna's may well conclude they have to choice but
to fight, and the Nicaraguan government would be complicit in the
bloodshed.
RELATED CONTENT
McMansion Mania We're supersizing in the suburbs, and we can't seem to stop September October 1999 ...
Something within us loves the land. Sees gentle hills, undulating dunes, and toothlike mountaintops...
What it really takes to be a sustainable tourist...
--
Brendan ThemesGo there >>Who Owns
the Forest?Related Links:Related Links from the Utne Archive:Comments? Story tips?
Write a letter to the editorLike this? Want
more?Subscribe
to Utne magazine