China's Other Great Wall
While the new superpower opens its doors to the world, its government cracks down on voices of dissent
July / August 2005
Jehangir S. Pocha Utne magazine
Last December,. a seemingly ambiguous story in the People's
Daily, a state-run English-language newspaper in China,
exhorted the country's youth to clean up their text messaging
habits. After being told that this relatively new form of
communication had 'degenerated into a haven for invective,
pornography, and insidious superstitious information aimed at
fouling our social ideology,' adolescents interested in cleansing
themselves were invited to enter a Decent Short Message Competition
cosponsored by the prestigious Peking and Renmin Universities. The
article concluded that 'in addition to such soft measures . . .
necessary legal provisions should also be implemented.'
RELATED CONTENT
Surfing to the Wailing Wall Jerusalem July August 1997 By Will Hermes, Utne Reader (commerce.cdsful...
The Blue Wall of Terror November 6, 2002 Issue By Erica Sagrans The Blue Wall of Terror, by Jess Wi...
The Writing's on the Wall...and the Jeans...and the T-shirt March 16, 2001 Anjula Razdan T...
Fly on the Wall Web Specials Archives Shermakaye Bass Escape (www.escapemag.com) Rock climbe...
To those adept at reading between the lines of China's media,
what happened next came as no surprise: Two months after the
article was published, the Ministry of Public Security announced
that it was rolling out a statewide text messaging monitoring
system. It was just another example of how China's Communist Party
is contradicting the Western assumption that free markets naturally
lead to freer societies.
China already has the highest number of imprisoned journalists
in the world -- at least 42, according to the New York-based
Committee to Protect Journalists. And, in large part because
President Hu Jintao's economic reforms are leaving a
disenfranchised (and vocal) lower class in their wake, the
government has become even more paranoid, repressive, and -- with
the help of U.S. technology-sophisticated.
In 2004, in areas far removed from the glass towers in cities
like Beijing and Shanghai, there were tens of thousands of protests
across China in response to everything from withheld pensions to
land seizures to government corruption. In an effort to keep these
minor uprisings from sparking a major political movement,
authorities typically sealed off areas affected by bouts of unrest
and detained print and broadcast journalists on the scene.
There are currently 80 million Chinese people connected to the
Internet, however, and one out of every four people owns a cell
phone, so simply exerting physical pressure on the more traditional
news outlets was no longer adequate.
'We are reaching the point where Web-based information is
acquiring a critical mass and totally bypassing traditional
censorship,' says Guo Liang, a professor of social development at
the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences in Beijing. 'The government
feels it cannot just let this happen.'
To remedy its problem, the Chinese government sought out a
number of U.S. technology companies, including Cisco Systems, which
has developed cutting-edge word recognition and filtering
techniques that bar access to more than 250,000 Web sites
(including pages hosted by Amnesty International and the BBC) and
scans e-mail, online chat forums, and blogs for offending
information. Armed with this new gadgetry and carte blanche to spy
on whomever they want, the 30,000 human monitors who now track
daily Internet usage have made China 'more successful than any
other country' in censoring the Web, according to the Harvard Law
School's Berkman Center for Internet and Society.