Drug vs. the Bug
Overuse of antibiotics may lower resistance to illness
Web Specials Archives
Sharon Parker Utne Reader
A few years ago I suffered a painful sinus infection, and visited a
physician, who told me, 'I used to prescribe two weeks of
antibiotics for this, but now I find that isn't enough, so I
prescribe three weeks of antibiotics.'
RELATED ARTICLES
America's most recent kind of civil war--the so-called...
Whether glamorizing or demonizing them, American movies crave drugs...
Biotech corporations are formulating the drug to end all drugs -- a vaccine against the 'disease' o...
The drug industry excels at turning reporters from watchdogs into lapdogs...
A new anti-war movement emerges, challenging the militarization of drug policy...
I then sought the advice of a naturopath (naturopathic treatment
avoids drugs), who gave me a homeopathic remedy that stopped the
pain immediately, and herbal teas that had my head cleared in less
than a week. When I told him I had been disappointed that the first
doctor offered no alternatives to antibiotics, he replied, 'That's
all she's got.'
Our very dependence on antibiotics appears to be bringing about
their demise. Some scientists are declaring a new medical crisis:
the emergence and rapid progression of antibiotic-resistant strains
of bacteria. Newsweek (March, 1995) magazine declared 'the
end of antibiotics' in a story documenting the many cases of
bacterial infections that would not respond to antibiotic
treatment. Time (Sept. 12, 1994) reported that several
strains of tuberculosis that can't be treated with common
antibiotics have emerged, and that even common staph and strep
infections are becoming increasingly difficult to treat.
The problem appears to be threefold: first, in the very origins
of the antibiotics, which Discover points out (Aug. 1994)
were first created by bacteria -- the penicillium mold. Therefore,
author Mark Caldwell reasons, it should come as no surprise that
bacteria 'might also be able to defend themselves from
attack.'Caldwell chalks this up to 'blind but relentless
evolution.'
Second, although bacteria would make these adaptations even if
we used antibiotics sparingly, overuse affords countless
opportunities for bacteria to get to know their enemy and
adapt.
Even though the evidence has been mounting that antibiotics are
not effective against most middle ear infections, particularly in
children, and may even contribute to recurring infections because
they interfere with the body's own immune system, the Centers for
Disease Control and Prevention reports that they are prescribed for
fluid in the middle ear 99 percent of the time.
In a report released last summer, the Project on Government
Oversight (PGO), an independent watchdog group in Washington, said
that a scholar at the National Academy of Science's Institute of
Medicine concluded that antibiotics were no more effective than
placebos in treating middle ear infections. Yet the Department of
Health and Human Services still recommends antibiotics for ear
infections.
This may be especially unfortunate if, as practitioners of
alternative medicine claim, most children who suffer recurring ear
infections have an allergy to some food, most often dairy products.
One ear, nose, and throat specialist in Florida, Dr. Fred Pullen,
has claimed that as many as 75 percent of children referred to him
to have tubes inserted in their ears because of chronic ear
infections responded so well to eliminating dairy products from
their diets that the surgery was unnecessary.