Invisible Ink

Notes for a living planet

Add to My MSN

Selling Climate Change

10/16/2012 3:34:25 PM

Tags: Perrier commercial, Diesel advertisements, global warming, climate change, advertising, Suzanne Lindgren

diesel global warming china wall
Sand rises around the Great Wall of China in a 2007 Diesel ad. Text in the upper right corner reads "global warming ready." 

Perhaps by now you’ve heard that Perrier, the sparkling water company, has come up with a way to fix climate change. Ring the bells. Bang the drums.

You’re probably wondering what the idea is. Are the people of Perrier campaigning to end subsidies to oil companies worldwide?

No.

Are they encouraging people to drive less, buy less stuff, and stop pillaging Planet Earth?

Ha!

More recycling?

Please.

The company’s plan is to send a lithe young woman into space to pour some sparkling water on the sun. Yes. That’s the plan.

Well, OK, not seriously—but they made a commercial about it. Because the sun is the problem, and putting it out is the solution.

 

Earth to Perrier, it’s 2012 calling. The record setting heat-waves, droughts, fires, and storms are only going to get worse. No one knows exactly what will happen but people generally agree that there will be disruptions to our supplies of food and water, not to mention changes to our habitats. There will be other consequences we haven’t predicted. Climate change isn’t a marketing gimmick, and shouldn’t be used as way to sell more stuff.

Because global warming is caused by general overconsumption, most advertising makes climate change worse, if indirectly. It’s not just that we drive too much and fly too much (though we do), it’s that everything we buy comes to us at cost to the planet. That includes sparkling water. It’s not that an advertisement like this is actually more harmful than any other ad, it’s just unforgivably irreverent.

Of course, Perrier is not the first to do this. Italian clothing brand Diesel offered a series of “Global Warming Ready” print ads in 2007. The ads featured young, wealthy–looking white people in post-climate-change settings around the world. Parrots have taken the place of pigeons at St. Mark’s Square in Venice. The Great Wall of China is half-covered in sand. Jungle wildlife encroaches on the Eiffel Tower and at Mount Rushmore, Lincoln’s nose is barely above water. The roofs of skyscrapers have become islands in Manhattan.

diesel global warming ny 

It doesn’t look so bad, really. I mean, if climate change is all about hanging out on rooftop beaches and looking fabulous, count me in. I’ll spend every last penny on high-end clothes and sparkling water. I’ll call it stocking up.

The strange thing is, as audacious as these ads seem, they’re also soothing. “Everything will be fine,” they whisper. “Buy more stuff.”

If the cause of climate-changing emissions is overconsumption—of fuel but also of products—then advertisements are a big part of the problem. Perrier and Diesel are not the sole offenders, but the last thing we need is reassurance that altered, extreme climates will be tolerable with new clothes and bottled water.

I questioned writing this post for a couple of reasons. First, I’m extending the reach of the ad to people who may have chosen to live outside advertising’s reach. People who don’t want to be manipulated into buying things. People who don’t want to waste time and energy chasing material goods beyond basic needs. Second, it would be very easy to derail my argument like so: Now here’s a person who takes everything too seriously. Can’t we just sit back at the end of a long, hard workday and watch TV? Advertising is just that, advertising. It doesn’t actually affect anyone. It’s not so bad, watching this imaginative commercial, with rich colors and beautiful people and a lovely sense of resolution. It makes me happy … and thirsty.  

It may be true that I have no sense of humor, but in a situation this grave, why should I? Our government is not responding to dangerous levels of pollution. Our president couldn’t be bothered to attend Rio+20. A group of children sued the Environmental Protection Agency for neglecting to protect the atmosphere, and the case was dismissed by a U.S. District Judge who claimed it was out of his jurisdiction. Our legislators are too busy collecting bribes from Big Oil and Big Industry to create policies that would make sustainability economically attractive.

This is a failure of leadership and a failure of the market. We must respond by making climate change a high priority within the culture. That does not start with soothing advertisements from companies trying to make a dollar before the unpredictable rises up around us. 



Related Content

Do Ads Make TV More Fun?

There’s an arms race taking place between advertisers and viewers, where people block out ads with T...

How to Have a Non-Commercial Holiday

Toys are fun, but what kids really need for Christmas is love, connection, and play time.

This Is Your Brain on Drug Commercials

Do you have depression? Achy face? Do you see the world in black and white? You may be stuck inside ...

Why Your On-Demand Programs Are Spying on You

Personalized ads will soon make the leap from the internet to your TV screen, using information cull...

Content Tools




Post a comment below.

 

GreenHearted
10/10/2013 7:41:18 PM
Interesting timing for me. We just had what seemed like a month of rain. The most depressing September in history. I had a gingerale with lunch at our local pub recently and it tasted sort of fishy. I thought it was me. A week or so later, I ordered a glass of water with dinner and got that fishy (or "off") taste again. The server explained that all the rain had mucked up our water sources. "Do you have anything in a can that I could drink?" I asked. Next thing I know, I'm drinking Perrier! So this post made me laugh. Yup, climate change and Perrier are definitely related.

Michael Moncrief
10/19/2012 9:28:30 PM
Maybe it is just me, but what if these ads that actually show examples of global warming (albeit unrealistic and silly versions) do instill in those who refuse to believe a subconscious notion that global warming is coming soon to a world near you???

SustainLandDev
10/19/2012 2:36:37 PM
Sustainable Land Development Initiative: Mitigating Climate Change - http://t.co/pljxMWgS http://t.co/4g9NJEhc

Bella Anda
10/19/2012 1:45:31 PM
Let me first say that I am not a Perrier drinker. I don't see the appeal other than something made popular by the hypocrites from Hollywood who drive electric cars but fly on personal jets. Other than that, Perrier put out an ad. It's sort of lame but they tried to give it an "avantgarde" twist, which clearly was not achieved. But to make it the subject of an editorial is completely silly.

Canis Calabrian
10/19/2012 1:28:15 PM
Thanks for this. More needs to be done to combat the meme that we can consume our way into a brighter future.



Pay Now & Save $5!
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Address: *
City: *
State/Province: *
Zip/Postal Code:*
Country:
Email:*
(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here

Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $5 and get 4 issues of Utne Reader for only $31.00 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $36 for 4 issues of Utne Reader!