The Death of Telling the Truth

Telling the truth sounds easy, but social and professional expectations increasingly dictate how honest we can be with one another.
By William Damon, from “Endangered Virtues”
May/June 2012
Add to My MSN

We seem to be reaching a dysfunctional tipping point in which an essential commitment to truthfulness no longer seems to be assumed in our society.
PEDRO X. MOLINA/PXMOLINA.COM


Content Tools

Related Content

Mushrooms and the Strange People Who Hunt Them

A delightful look at the cult of the mushroom....

Pop Songs and Noble Truths of the Buddha

Lou Rawls famously sang, “Love Is a Hurting Thing.” Little did he know that he was illuminating the ...

Truth, Lies, and Bird-Watching

Perhaps our cynical society should take a cue from bird watchers, who tend to trust one another and ...

The Carbon Tax Will Kill Us All

I recently learned that the carbon tax is part of a secret, intra-governmental plot to kill 80 perce...

People do not always stick to the truth when they speak. Some of the reasons are justifiable—for example, humane considerations such as tact and the avoidance of greater harm. Reassuring an ungainly teenager that he or she looks great may be a kind embroidery of the truth. In a more consequential instance, misinforming storm troopers about the whereabouts of a hidden family during the Nazi occupation of Europe was an honorable and courageous deception.

Compassion, diplomacy, and life-threatening circumstances sometimes require a departure from the entire unadulterated truth. Some vocations seem to demand occasional deception for success or survival. Politicians, for example, are especially hard-pressed to tell the truth consistently. Perhaps this is because, as George Orwell once observed, the very function of political speech is to hide, soften, or misrepresent difficult truths. It would be naive (or cynical) for anyone in today’s world to act shocked when a politician tries to hide the real truth from the public.

Yet to recognize that honesty is not an absolute standard, and that we can expect a certain amount of deceit from even our respected public figures, is not to say that the virtue of honesty can be disregarded with impunity. A basic intent to be truthful, along with an assumption that people can be generally taken at their word, is required for all sustained civilized dealings.

No civilization can tolerate a fixed expectation of dishonest communications without falling apart from a breakdown in mutual trust. All human relations rely upon confidence that those in the relations will, as a rule, tell the truth. Honesty builds and solidifies a relationship with trust; too many breaches in honesty can corrode relations beyond repair. Friendships, family, work, and civic relations all suffer whenever dishonesty comes to light. The main reason that no one wants to be known as a liar is that people shun liars.

Although truthfulness is essential for good human relationships and personal integrity, it is often abandoned in pursuit of other life priorities. Indeed, there may be a perception in many key areas of contemporary life—law, business, and politics, among others—that expecting honesty on a regular basis is a naive and foolish attitude, a “loser’s” way of operating. Such a perception is practically a mandate for personal dishonesty and a concession to interpersonal distrust. When we no longer assume that those who communicate with us are at least trying to tell the truth, we give up on them as trustworthy persons and deal with them only in a strictly instrumental manner. The bounds of mutual moral obligation dissolve, and the laws of the jungle reemerge.

We seem to be reaching a dysfunctional tipping point in which an essential commitment to truthfulness no longer seems to be assumed in our society. If this is indeed the case, the danger is that the bonds of trust that are important in any society, and essential for a free and democratic one, will dissolve so that the kinds of discourse required to self-govern will become impossible.

William Damon is a senior fellow at the Hoover Institution at Stanford University. Excerpted from Endangered Virtues (2011), an online volume of essays published by the Hoover Institution Task Force on Virtues of a Free Society. 


Previous | 1 | 2 | Next






Post a comment below.

 

Ec Graham
5/18/2012 1:55:13 PM
I agree with Kimball. It's simplistic to think in terms of absolute truths and comments like the one below seem to be desperately shaped by some kind of fear based evangelical idea (albeit Hindu) about the truth. As Herodotus said many years ago, "culture is king"—and the "truths" of how to live, what to live for, have always been defined by cultures (and before globalization that was easier to see.) Having said that, absolute relativism about "the truth" plunges us into the predicament of reality shaped by subjectivity. This is a far more complex debate than meets the eye.

SONYA CRANK
5/17/2012 5:11:51 AM
Is it any wonder that so many people are reluctant to vote in elections when an honest politician is becoming an endangered species?

Shriram Darbha
5/17/2012 5:08:22 AM
As a matter of 'fact', How can 'TRUTH' be multifaceted??Truth is always absolute and people may interpret/manipulate as per their convenience. That doesn't make it multifaceted. If TRUTH were to be otherwise there can never be truth. How would one depend/trust anything or anyone. The article is not disappointing, as he is expressing his disappointment with the way of the world. Absolute 'TRUTHs are commandments and they will not and should not change. Else there is nothing to AIM for in life, no meaning, and we would be back to jungle. We call it eternal TRUTH/Principles as DHARMA in INDIA and the society for time immemorial followed, benefited, lead peaceful life. Its only when 'Relativity' is attributed to TRUTH the world order changed and we know the result. Thats the 'Reality.

GWYNN O'NEILL
5/16/2012 7:51:20 PM
"Seek ye the truth, for the truth shall make you free." Close quote of Jesus from Nazareth.

Ruby Love
5/16/2012 5:05:18 PM
Insightful essay! I agree that the old adage " believe nothing of what you hear and only half of what you see" could be a subtitle here although it does not imply a new "tipping point" but recognizes human nature. Evolutionary biology has shown that "lying" is not species-specific and shifts the odds of success (politics, business, etc.) in one's favor (unless the lie is exposed). Assumption of truth-telling hasn't been part of society for a very long time and most people are aware of this "truth." This article pumps up the volume on an old cliche.

David Kimball
5/16/2012 2:39:02 PM
I was disappointed with this article. It equates "truth" with "true/false". They are not the same. Our rational mind operates with the language of logic and creates a world where something is either True or False. However, our intuitive mind uses the language of metphores and stories to discern Truth. There can be many truths to a situation - ans some of these may even be opposite of each other. When we try to place Truth in the binary situation, it will seldom be completely True. This distinction is important to recognize so we can expect Truth to be multi-faceted.


MY COMMUNITY
no image
Rosemary Campbell
9/29/2014 12:13:03 PM
no image
Rosemary Campbell
9/29/2014 11:58:26 AM
no image
baguspedia
9/25/2014 11:07:10 PM
no image
baguspedia
9/25/2014 11:00:38 PM
no image
PernilleJuels
9/25/2014 1:15:30 AM
no image
karlenefrank
9/24/2014 6:58:04 AM
no image
Anneroberts1519
9/24/2014 6:50:41 AM
no image
stevejonson
9/23/2014 7:04:11 AM






Pay Now & Save $5!
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Address: *
City: *
State/Province: *
Zip/Postal Code:*
Country:
Email:*
(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here

Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $5 and get 4 issues of Utne Reader for only $31.00 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $36 for 4 issues of Utne Reader!