Utne Blogs > Environment

A (New) Climate Question

by Cally Carswell 


Tags: Environment, Election 2008, climate change, global warming, presidential debates, Bill McKibben, Grist, Gristmill,

In a presidential debate dominated by questions about economic uncertainty and foreign policy, climate change made an appearance in a subtly new way. It was only one question, asked by a 30-year old university student named Ingrid Jackson. But the way she posed it, climate change activist Bill McKibben writes on Gristmill, prompted “as close to a real breakthrough as I've seen.”

After noting that Congress worked pretty quickly to address the financial crisis, Jackson wanted to know what the candidates would do in their first two years in office to take on climate change and other environmental issues.

“After approximately 4 million debates over the past year,” writes McKibben, “someone finally asked the right and real question about climate change.” For McKibben, who has been speaking out against climate change for two decades, this small moment signaled a major shift in the great global warming debate. He says Jackson asked the right question by skipping past tired points of contention like "Is it real?" and "Is it manmade?" opting instead to challenge the candidates with a pressing timetable. He also found it remarkable that “their point of disagreement was over who had fought harder for alternative energy in the Senate.” According to McKibben, “it was a way of saying that all serious folks, even if they disagree on tax policy or the war in Iraq, understand that an adult and mature America must take on global warming.”

Jackson, who spoke with Grist after the debate, was satisfied with some parts of the candidates’ answers, but didn’t feel “either one dealt with the urgency issue.” She said she asked the question because the environment has concerned her for a long time, and it too often places low on political priority lists behind issues like Iraq and the economy. “The only time [candidates] deal with the environment is … well, actually, they don’t seem to be dealing with it at all,” she said.

 

justin_1
10/10/2008 2:42:57 AM

"He says Jackson asked the right question by skipping past tired points of contention like 'Is it real?' and 'Is it manmade?'" What McKibben calls "the right question," educated people call "the logical fallacy of the compound question." It is like asking someone in court "How long have you been beating your wife?" It FIRST has to be established that the man has been beating his wife. Since science has yet to establish that the sky is falling and that man is the cause, the question is based on a false premise. http://www.petitionproject.org/