Manitoba Cree Tribe Calls Foul on Utility

They blame dams for ruining livelihoods, environment

| January-February 2000

As they plug in their toasters or watch a lightbulb flicker to life, most Midwesterners are blissfully unaware of a battle raging at the source of their electricity, far away in Canada. But thanks to the efforts of a small Cree tribe in northern Manitoba, that could change. The Cross Lake Crees are enlisting the support of environmentalists and human rights organizations in their fight against Manitoba Hydro, a utility company they claim has destroyed their livelihoods and environment. They’ve taken their cause to the streets of Minneapolis, rallying at the offices of Northern States Power Co. (NSP)—which buys much of Manitoba Hydro's electricity—and holding informational meetings with anyone who will listen. The campaign has one goal: to turn NSP away from Manitoba Hydro’s cheap power and force the Canadian utility to agree to an acceptable compensation package for the tribe.

“It has turned our way of life upside down here,” says Nelson Miller, a band councillor with the Cross Lake First Nation, a troubled aboriginal community nestled deep in the forests of northern Manitoba, about 300 miles north of Winnipeg. Their struggle with Manitoba Hydro began in the 1970s, when the construction of three dams on the Nelson River caused widespread flooding. The dams, which generate about 80 percent of Manitoba Hydro’s power, displaced whole communities and irreparably damaged traditional hunting and fishing grounds. In 1977, five native communities, including Cross Lake, signed the Northern Flood Agreement (NFA) with the Canadian government, Manitoba’s provincial government, and Manitoba Hydro for compensation. Since then, all but Cross Lake have taken lump sum payouts. The band wants the NFA signers to live up to the broad terms of the agreement, which promised greater compensation for present and future generations to help wipe out numbing unemployment and poverty.

As in many aboriginal communities, most of the band's 4,000 reserve residents cannot find work; alcohol, drug abuse, and suicide are rampant. Since 1976, 22 people on the reserve have taken their own lives, twice the national average. “These people are living with so much uncertainty it’s got to take a toll on their mental health,” says Ann Stewart, who was hired by the band to serve as its U.S. information officer. She has been leading the charge in the United States, meeting with environmental, human rights, faith, and aboriginal groups in the hopes of winning their support and, in turn, creating a powerful lobby to force NSP to turn its back on Manitoba Hydro when its contract expires in 2005.

So far, says Stewart, the campaign has been a tremendous success, with groups such as the state chapter of the Sierra Club and the Clean Water Action Alliance of Minnesota forming alliances with the Cross Lake Cree. After all, she says, there is almost as much at stake for those living in the American Midwest as for the Canadian Cree Indians. “The biggest issue is that we don’t know the social and environmental costs of the electricity,” says Stewart.

And those costs are unacceptably high, both for the Cross Lake Cree and for the U.S. environmental movement, says Kate Kempton, a Toronto-based legal adviser and strategist for the Cross Lake band. “Buying that power hurts the Crees and the northern Manitoba environment, yes. But our position is that it likely also hurts Minnesotans and other American states, because there seems to be a strong correlation between the purchase of cheap hydroelectricity—which this is—and displacement of their conservation programs and the development of true renewables, like wind.”

But don’t hold your breath waiting for wind power to replace hydroelectricity. NSP has no intention of giving up Manitoba’s cheap hydro anytime soon, says Audrey Zibelman, the company’s president of energy marketing. “Hydro power is a very important part of the fuel mix that allows us to provide electricity at a low cost, and reliably, to [our] customers,” says Zibelman. “For people to suggest that we can eliminate hydro and turn to wind is highly naive.” Not only is wind power far more expensive than hydroelectricity, she says, it’s not plentiful enough to meet customer demand.

Pay Now Save $5!

Utne Summer 2016Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $5 and get 4 issues of Utne Reader for only $40.00 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $45 for 4 issues of Utne Reader!

Facebook Instagram Twitter

click me