One comic's crusade has sparked a heated debate on plagiarism in the funny business
Most comics don't have the restraint to keep a good joke to themselves. Yet when their own joke comes out of another's mouth, every comic cries foul. Unlike other professionals of the word -- screenwriters, poets, novelists -- comics rarely have the luxury of copyright laws to protect their work. By the same token, plagiarism is nearly impossible for a comic to prevent. The nature of the profession, which thrives on mostly unrecorded stand-up performances at comedy clubs, leaves no documentation to protect against fellow comics in the audience stealing the jokes that get the most laughs.
Traditionally, stealing jokes and the ensuing battles over authorship is a behind-the-scenes affair. The comic and actor Joe Rogan, however, brought comedy's cardinal sin to a public audience when he confronted Comedy Central's primetime star Carlos Mencia on stage at the Comedy Store in Los Angeles this past February. The ugly spat found its way to YouTube, where close to a million people have watched the video in the past six months. But to a greater effect, feud has brought attention to an issue that was once only the worry of comedians.
The many claims against Mencia's alleged comic thievery were an occasion for Gelf Magazine's Adam Conner-Simons to explore the unwritten ethics of stand-up comedy. He finds that for purists like comedian Steve Hofstetter, 'The root of comedy is truth, and if you're doing someone else's truth, you're not doing comedy.'
What constitutes telling the truth, however, and stealing a joke is a murky matter for some. Comedy Central's Skyler Stone tells the magazine, 'There's so much parallel thinking because we [comics] are all trying to tap into the same public consciousness.' So jokes about current issues -- like the absurdity of building a wall along the US-Mexican border -- end up sounding like an echo chamber on comedy circuits.
Of the countless comics making the rounds on the scene, only the handful with television exposure and CD releases are able to stamp a joke as their own and have any legal force behind it. These are the same comedians, however, that can use a copyright to lay claim to hijacked material. Radar's Larry Getlen explains the situation like this: 'When a comedian is the first to tell a stolen joke at a major gig or on national television, the public associates the material with that comic... A comedian can write the best joke of his career only to lose it to a sort of 'finders keepers' rule.'
The way some comics give a lifted joke their own spin can make it difficult to cry foul and have those charges hold in court. According to Getlen, legally challenging another comic has few advantages. It would be akin to the Beatles suing the Rolling Stones for using the same three chords in a two-minute pop song. Instead of going to court, comic Lisa Lampanelli tells the magazine that the best way for comics to get back at joke thieves is for them to keep doing their jobs. 'If you're gonna be a freakin' baby and whine that somebody stole your jokes, guess what?' she quips. 'You can write more.'
Or, take revenge. As Rogan's oft-viewed showdown with Mencia suggests, the internet might be the best police force to combat today's comedic pickpockets. By uploading material to sites like YouTube, comedians can protect themselves from the vultures circling their hard-won routines. The method forces the burden of proof from the accuser to the accused, effectively creating an ad hoc registry of comedy copyright. Plus, it's more laughs for the rest of us.
Go there >> No Joking Matter
Go there, too >> Take the Funny and Run
Related Links from the Utne Reader Archive:
Comments? Story tips? Write a letter to the editor
Like this? Want more? Subscribe to Utne Reader