Gray Wolves to the Slaughter

Gray Wolves are in trouble now that they’re no longer classified as endangered.

| July/August 2012

  • Wolf-Talking
    Canis lupus, the largest of the planet’s wild dogs, once numbered in the hundreds of thousands in the U.S. The creatures are powerful—the largest males, six and a half feet from tooth to tail, weigh 140 pounds—and they are agile and cunning.
  • Wolves-And-Carcass
    The ranching industry in the American West has been the historic enemy of wolves, so it was fitting that ranchers in Montana and Idaho called for hunting them almost from the moment of their reintroduction.
  • Wolves-Lounging
    Today, as a result of the delisting, anyone can shoot a wolf. Wolves can, in some circumstances, be shot on sight.

  • Wolf-Talking
  • Wolves-And-Carcass
  • Wolves-Lounging

In April 2001, a U.S. government wildlife trapper named Carter Niemeyer choppered into the mountains of central Idaho to slaughter a pack of wolves whose alpha female was famed for her whiteness. He hung from the open door of the craft with a semiautomatic shotgun, the helicopter racing over the treetops. Then, in a clearing, Niemeyer caught a glimpse of her platinum fur. Among wolf lovers in Idaho, she was called Alabaster, and she was considered a marvel—most wolves are brown or black or gray. People all over the world had praised Alabaster, had written about her, had longed to see her in the flesh. Livestock ranchers in central Idaho, whose sheep and cows graze in wolf country, felt otherwise. They claimed Alabaster and her pack—known as the Whitehawks—threatened the survival of their herds, which in turn threatened the rural economy of the high country. She had to be exterminated.

When Alabaster appeared in Niemeyer’s sights, a hundred feet below the helicopter, her ears recoiled from the noise and the rotor wash, but she was not afraid. She labored slowly along a ridge, looking, Niemeyer says, “like something out of a fairy tale.”

Then he shot her. At the time, wolves were considered a rare species in Idaho and across the Northern Rockies, and they were protected under the Endangered Species Act. But they could be targeted for “lethal control” if they made trouble—if they threatened a human being, which almost never happened, or, more commonly, if they were implicated in attacking cattle and sheep. The Whitehawks allegedly had been enjoying a good number of cows and sheep that spring and were said to have killed at least one rancher’s guard dog.

As a trapper for the U.S. Department of Agriculture and later as a wolf expert for the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Niemeyer was trained to control predators. In 26 years working for the government, he had killed thousands of coyotes. But wolves are a different kind of kill. As predators, they are exquisite. Niemeyer had taken a liking to wolves. He respected them. When he necropsied Alabaster at the kill site—gutting her, stripping her pelt—he found she was pregnant with nine pups that were two weeks from birth, almost fully formed. He buried each pup.

Canis lupus, the largest of the planet’s wild dogs, once numbered in the hundreds of thousands in the U.S. The creatures are powerful—the largest males, six and a half feet from tooth to tail, weigh 140 pounds—and they are agile and cunning. They run in packs of seven to ten animals that consist of a father and mother—the alphas—along with pups and subordinate males and females, unrelated to the family but welcomed in their midst. The wolf is an apex predator, at the top of its food chain, keeping prey from overpopulating, which maintains a balanced ecosystem.

With European settlement and the decimation of its native prey—buffalo, elk, mule deer—the wolf was bound for destruction. It was now killing for its meals the domesticated sheep and cattle that settlers had ranged across the grasslands and the mountains. Hated for its depredations, the wolf was hunted mercilessly. By 1935, the gray wolf had disappeared almost entirely from the U.S.

Denise Winarchick
8/3/2012 9:38:25 PM

So.....Alabaster was killed by someone who wanted her pelt as a souvenir. This is all ego driven. I feel bad for people like this because with their beliefs in their superiority, they show their ignorance. They try to justify their behavior by thinking that it is a needed service that they perform. Maybe one day, they will understand.

Jeff Biss
8/3/2012 4:59:23 PM

There's a human problem, not a wolf problem. Solve the human problem. The problem can be sourced to the fact that people have exalted a) themselves above accountability for the harm they cause those they don't value and (b) their desires above the needs of those they don't value thus conflating need with want. Humans have created religions that allow them to perform evil, as in killing other sentient beings for no valid reason as humans under no circumstance require meat to sustain life or health and thus definitely have no right to consider that the universe revolves around us. In fact, as moral beings we have the obligation to minimize the harm we cause those we don't value. to do otherwise is by default evil.

Gary Lore
8/3/2012 3:20:12 PM

An excellent article, albeit seriously flawed by one very notable error: beavers don't eat trout. It's that sort of hyperbole that gives the anti-wolf welfare ranchers fodder for their cause. The key here is that a balanced ecosystem requires wolves to remain healthy. I suggest an open season on the wolf-killers, just to help provide such balance. Please don't call them hunters, a real hunter understands that wolves and other predators are necessary for the survival of the elk, the deer, and the environment they all require. I suggest reading Aldo Leopold's Sand County Almanac and Edward Abbey's essays for greater insight.

Pay Now Save $5!

Utne Summer 2016Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $5 and get 4 issues of Utne Reader for only $40.00 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $45 for 4 issues of Utne Reader!

Facebook Instagram Twitter