Organ Donors on Death Row?

| 3/28/2008 5:36:40 PM

Some look at death row inmates and see the vilest people in the world. Others see victims awaiting murder by the state. Graeme Wood sees organs—viable transplant organs.

Writing for Good, he argues that the methods used to dispatch the inmates make it impossible to harvest their organs for transplants. Instead, he suggests using “the Mayan Protocol,” a process developed by, yes, the Mayans through vivisecting human sacrifices. In this method the organ removal becomes the means of execution. “If this sounds inhumane,” Wood writes, “compare it to current practices: botched hangings, painfully long gassings, and messy electrocutions. Removal of the heart, lungs, and kidneys (under anesthesia, of course) would kill every time, without an instant of pain.”

Such a practice would undoubtedly face hurdles. It has been a long-standing practice that doctors don’t murder patients, a tenet that has prevented them from participating in lethal injections. There is also the concern of consent. Inmates may agree to donate their organs as a way to curry support with judges or prison guards. Wood argues, however, that the real objection to the Mayan Protocol would be symbolic. Victims of families and the public in general don’t want criminals martyred for an altruistic cause.

And, of course, there is the creep factor:

But being creeped out is the price of living in a society that kills its criminals. If organ harvesting would make executions uncomfortably like human sacrifice, perhaps that’s because our death chambers are already gory enough to make anyone but a Mayan high priest pale.

An interesting point, but perhaps our energies could be better spent when it comes to death row reformation. As one commenter on the article notes: Why discuss the best way to kill inmates when we should be trying to end capital punishment?

4/3/2008 12:12:19 PM

Don't see the difference between institutionaled powerless pregnant persons to term for the purpose of harvesting womb-fresh newborns (for transfer to infertiles) and the harvesting death-row inmates for organs... except that maybe the pregnant teen is even more innocent and defenseless.

3/30/2008 3:54:14 PM

What I find entirely ironic and counterintuitive about the whole idea behind a death row inmate organ donor is the fact that on one of the many questionnaires one is required to answer prior to donating blood, there is always a question regarding whether you have spent any time in jail or not. Typically, anyone who has spent any time in jail is considered to be a poor candidate as a blood donor as the experience of imprisonment is assumed to place that individual at risk of exposure to intravenous drug use, poor tattoo practices, and rape/sexual molestation - all high risk activities associated with increasing incidences of HIV/AIDS. And now we're considering donating their organs?

Pay Now Save $5!

Utne Summer 2016Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $5 and get 4 issues of Utne Reader for only $40.00 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $45 for 4 issues of Utne Reader!

Facebook Instagram Twitter