Revolution in Paradise

Native Hawaiians struggle to reclaim their sovereignty

| September-October 1999

Though the aloha state might seem an idyllic paradise to legions of camera-toting, lei-wearing tourists who beach themselves on the islands each year, the reality is far from picture perfect. Native Hawaiians, descendants of the original inhabitants of the Hawaiian archipelago, are not only the least educated, poorest, and sickest segment of the population, they also feel that Hawaii has lost its cultural anchor and set age-old traditions and beliefs adrift in a sea of kitsch.

Tens of thousands of Hawaiians are involved in a sovereignty movement that aims to change the lot of the native population, which constitutes just one-fifth of Hawaii's 1 million residents, and bring back its true culture. And though the movement expresses myriad views, at its heart is the belief that native Hawaiians can govern themselves far better than the state and federal governments have done.

Natives believe their right to self-determination stems from the forcible overthrow of the Kingdom of Hawaii and its monarch, Queen Liliuyokalani, in 1893. With the assistance of the U.S. Marines and the support of the trade minister (but without the approval of Congress or President Grover Cleveland), the coup was led by American businessmen with stakes in the pineapple and sugar trades who feared the queen would create laws restricting their operations.

The phrase aloha `aina, literally "love land," forms the basis of traditional Hawaiian religion and culture. In simplest terms, it describes an interdependent relationship: The land nurtures you, and, in turn, you nurture the land. Activists say it was a reawakening of aloha `aina that gave the sovereignty movement its start.

In 1976 the Navy was using Kaho'olawe island (eight miles south of Maui) for bombing practice, as it had done since 1941. Seeing the destruction the shells were wreaking on the ecosystem and sacred sites, a group of protesters staged a series of landings on the island. Since then the movement has grown and matured. As many as 300 sovereignty groups operated at one time, some with just one or two members; today there are fewer than 20. "Nowadays the groups are getting more organized," says Healani Sonota, a legislator with Ka Láhui Hawai`i, one of the oldest and most active sovereignty groups, boasting more than 18,000 members. Ka Láhui Hawai`i advocates creation of a self-governing nation recognized by the federal government, similar to what Native Americans have. Other groups favor a formally recognized state within the existing state of Hawaii or a totally autonomous nation existing outside federal control.

Despite such factions, the sovereignty movement has seen much progress in the '90s. In 1993 Congress passed a resolution apologizing to native Hawaiians for the overthrow. A year later, the Pentagon transferred the deed of Kaho'olawe island to the state of Hawaii to be held in trust until the formation of "a sovereign Hawaiian nation." And in 1996 native Hawaiians voted to elect a Native Hawaiian Convention, scheduled to convene this year. "[The convention] is a possible, if controversial, first step toward some form of sovereignty," writes Dana Takagi in ColorLines (Spring 1999).

Pay Now Save $5!

Utne Summer 2016Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $5 and get 4 issues of Utne Reader for only $40.00 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $45 for 4 issues of Utne Reader!

Facebook Instagram Twitter