The Politics of T-Shirts and Fallen Soldiers

| 12/20/2007 4:52:01 PM

They DiedA recent article in Reason about bans on certain anti-war T-shirts made me think back on one of the saddest events of the past year for me. A friend from high school was killed in Iraq in January, and his family threw a good-bye party at the local watering hole for his friends to get together, drink, and tell funny stories about a kid we’d never see again. If you’re lucky enough to have never been to one of these memorials, there are a few things you should know. First, the venues tend to have one of two things in common: a close proximity to God (churches, synagogues, etc.) or easy access to booze (typically a bar or a VFW with a bar). Second, they’re heartrending. Dead young people always are. But the context—a violent death in a faraway country—gives them an even sadder underpinning. Third, there are T-shirts for sale. Always T-shirts. The proceeds usually go to the soldier’s family or a charity—both deserving recipients. 

Sadly, this tradition of memorializing dead soldiers is in iffy legal standing in a handful of states. The legal battle began with a Flagstaff, Arizona, anti-war protester who was selling T-shirts that read “Bush Lied...They Died” superimposed over the names of U.S. soldiers killed in Iraq. An Oklahoma mother, whose son is one of the soldiers named on the shirt, raised objections. In response, Oklahoma legislators imposed a ban on merchandise containing soldiers’ names and images in April 2006. Louisiana, Texas, and Florida all followed suit. And in May 2007, Arizona legislators unanimously passed a bill (free registration required) that made the commercial use of soldiers’ names and images without the consent of their families a misdemeanor crime. But, as Reason notes, “Such bans are almost certainly unconstitutional, since the shirts, though exchanged for money, are clearly political speech.”

Bush LiedThough prohibitions on the state level have weathered considerable opposition—in September a federal judge in Arizona issued a preliminary injunction against the law—U.S. Representatives Dan Boren (R-OK) and Charles Boustany (R-LA) pushed for a national ban in the House version of the 2008 Defense Authorization bill. Amid objections from the American Civil Liberties Union (pdf) and other free-speech advocacy groups, the ban didn’t survive the House/Senate conference committee that hashed out a compromised bill. The issue is far from dead, however. The conference committee requested independent studies by the Secretary of Defense and the Congressional Research Service focusing on legal reviews of the proposal.

Such laws, either on a state or federal level, are not only an infringement on free speech; they paint the grieving families of fallen soldiers—or anybody else, for that matter—as un-American if they come out against the war. If proponents of these misguided laws can somehow reconcile their cliché-ridden idea of the “ultimate sacrifice”—which these families have certainly made—with unpatriotic behavior, I’d love to see it. Until then, legislators should keep their laws off our dead friends.

Morgan Winters

12/28/2007 9:27:37 AM

i think the t-shirts are a part of free speech. if arizona thinks they should stop using soldiers names without their families permission, how about banning war memorials? would that be acceptable? (and by the way, the memorials ARE being sold. contractors are paid to make them.) KEEP YOUR LAWS OFF MY FREE SPEECH-- oops, too late.

Liz THomson
12/27/2007 3:56:59 PM

IN my opinion - Tshirts and other antiwar statements - should be left alone - they are , in essence free speech. A lot of those who have not experienced the death of a son/daughter/friend, tend ignore the realities of death - what it is - its violence, its permanence - its ability to destroy families and more. IT is time we all woke up . These young people are being sent to war - they are dying - THEY DIED.

12/27/2007 2:55:16 PM

"......military men are dumb stupid animals to be used as pawns in foreign policy....." henry kissinger sec.of state (nixon add.) from 'the final days' war criminal extrodinaire and truly pathetic human being

Pay Now Save $5!

Utne Summer 2016Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $5 and get 4 issues of Utne Reader for only $40.00 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $45 for 4 issues of Utne Reader!

Facebook Instagram Twitter

click me