Using Democracy to Dismantle Democracy

With progressive rhetoric and staggering grabs of presidential power some Latin American presidents have deconstructed democracy

| November-December 2010

  • Using-Democracy-to-Dismantle

    Pablo Lobato /

  • Using-Democracy-to-Dismantle

Latin American presidents Hugo Chávez, Rafael Correa, and Evo Morales are often touted for their seemingly progressive policies, expressed in populist platforms that promise to provide for the poor and restore power to the people.  

The fiery journal Dissent (Summer 2010) believes these darlings of North America’s alternative press urgently require closer inspection, arguing that their regimes in Venezuela, Ecuador, and Bolivia (respectively) represent an alarming regional trend—using democracy to dismantle democracy.  

“Opportunistic political elites don’t have to break the law when the rule of law is so weak—and public and private institutions are so pliable—that the constitution can simply be refashioned,” write Forrest D. Colburn and Alberto Trejos, professors at the INCAE Business School, which has campuses in Nicaragua and Costa Rica. These Latin American governments have been turned into “the latest and most fashionable incarnation of dictatorship”—not progress—they argue.  

Progressive rhetoric helped pave the way. In Venezuela in the late ’90s, Chávez’s new constitution was heralded “as a ‘refounding’ of the nation-state,” the scholars write, “necessary to correct historical injustices and to focus public policy on meeting the needs of the impoverished majority.” It also downsized the number of elected officials and lengthened their terms, concentrating the president’s political power and enabling a sweeping nationalization of resources. Promises to the majority, on the other hand, remain largely unfulfilled. Between 2007 and 2008, Correa and Morales also pushed through new constitutions plastered with populist values and resulting in similarly staggering grabs of presidential power.  

The strategic mimicry is no coincidence, according to Colburn and Trejos. All three presidents received counsel from the same set of legal scholars, led by Roberto Viciano Pastor, a constitutional law professor at the University of Valencia. His intentions may be noble, Colburn and Trejos write, but the effect is deconstructing democracy in the region. The leaders have yet to produce a social “payoff” for their reforms, and “by wrecking democratic institutions, presidents like Chávez, Correa, and Morales are not only subverting the rights of their opponents, they are also leaving tomorrow’s majority without a voice.”

12/29/2010 1:16:02 PM

This article seems pretty vague, lacking specific examples.

12/19/2010 7:48:55 AM

Rather than concentrate on the problems of Latin America, we should first take care of what's happening around us. We have a congress and senate made up in bulk by millionaire lawyers. Just what kind of "representation" do we really have from millionaire lawyers? We only have to look at the current state of the economy and the nation itself to see what those millionaire lawyers have done to us. I feel sick every time I go in to vote because I generally have to choose between two millionaire lawyers, neither of which will represent me nor any of the people like me who do not have thousands of dollars in our pockets to lavish upon our "representatives." We are totally out of the system and have no real say in what they do to us.

12/15/2010 12:14:34 PM

Colin Cowherd (ESPN radio commentator) expresses a great deal of frustration (although it works on his behalf often) with local sports radio hosts protecting "their team" at all costs. This relates in the same regard as Kristen's post talking about America right or wrong. I know alot of people, including good friends, who won't entertain or even discuss any ideas other than the ones they believe. Right or Wrong is neither.

Pay Now Save $5!

Utne Summer 2016Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $5 and get 4 issues of Utne Reader for only $40.00 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $45 for 4 issues of Utne Reader!

Facebook Instagram Twitter