When Public Libraries Go Private


| 1/14/2008 2:52:22 PM


Tags: Public libraries, outsourcing, privatizing libraries,

LibraryThe public library is treasured even by people who rarely use it. Along with book-borrowing privileges and research tools, the library offers something more fundamental: As a public, local institution, it defends intellectual freedom and supports and responds to the particular needs and interests of a community.

At least, it used to. More and more, a library’s civic function depends on where you live. Writing for In These Times, Akito Yoshikane recently reported that Library Systems and Services (LSSI), a private, Maryland-based company, now runs 50 “public” libraries across the United States. 

When funding issues force communities to consider permanently closing their libraries, outsourcing to LSSI can be a relatively attractive alternative. According to its website, the company can make a library “operate more effectively at lower cost per hour.” According to Yoshikane, the company accomplishes this by, among other things, downsizing staff, reducing hours, and passing costs on to patrons. And it keeps a portion of the community’s library budget as profit. What’s more, libraries that outsource core services to LSSI lose the local oversight typical of public libraries.

Not everyone is quietly accepting library privatization as an inevitable result of a free market and limited public funds. Local campaigns have defeated outsourcing initiatives, and, in at least one county, the Service Employees International Union local has gotten involved. Also, as Yoshikane notes, “the ALA [American Library Association] council adopted a stance opposing outsourcing, stating that libraries are ‘not a simple commodity’ but ‘are an essential public good.’ ”

(For a wider look at the state of public libraries, see this 2005 article from the Utne Reader.)

Steve Thorngate

katherine s. harris_3
1/17/2008 1:28:58 AM

After earning my degree, I worked in the Science and Technology Department of the Boston Public Library, a long time ago. Two summers ago, I was in Boston and went by to visit the Library. I asked at the Reception Desk for directions to my old Department. "Oh, there is no Science and Technology Department any more!", was the reply, "It's included the Humanities now". I felt as though someone had ripped a page out of my life, and asked whether the Dewey Decimal System had also been discarded! Now I understand the Boston Public Library may have fallen prey to a private business takeover. Unthinkable!!!!!!!! Katherine S. Harris http://belsitoartgallery.com


adolfo preciado
1/16/2008 11:20:27 PM

As a Mexican who has lived, and frequently visits the US, I say that your public libraries are a treasure you should keep at all costs. A public library, even in the smallest communities is a refreshing sight. Keep business out!!