Does the Great White North Deserve Its Green Reputation?

Canada ranked an impressive fourth of all countries rated in the
Environmental Sustainability Index while the United States placed a
dismal 45th, ‘but when it comes to allowing extractive industries
to run rampant, Canada may be king,’ writes E/The Environmental
‘s John Holt, an American who seeks to dispel the myth
that Canadian developers and raw-material extractors have no blood
on their hands. In fact, coalminers and loggers are doing to some
of the last great wilderness on Earth what’s already been done to
states like Montana, Wyoming and West Virginia.

Food for thought: Three-hundred million acres of Canadian forest
(one-and-a-half times the size of some Midwestern states) are
slotted for timber production even though these fragile lands are
home to two-thirds of the country’s 300,000 wildlife species.
Canada’s forests cover an area nearly three times the size of
Europe, or 10 percent of the world’s forest cover, but only 5.5
percent of this is under some form of legal protection or
constraint related to logging. ‘This is some of the most productive
forest in terms of biomass in the world,’ Holt states. But ‘if
present trends continue, all of Canada’s suitable forest will
harvested within 30 to 35 years.’

Holt includes his own personal observations, mourning the
metamorphosis of Rocky Mountain House, Alberta, once a ‘rather
sedate town of a few thousand sometimes-impoverished souls who
enjoyed life on the bluffs above the North Fork of the Saskatchewan
River,’ which has succumbed to ‘a riot of oil rigs, logging trucks,
related workers, and the destructiveness that comes from too much
money deposited in a local economy way too quickly.’ He summarizes,
‘The continual boom-and-bust cycle of the West is at play in
Canada. Ten, maybe 20 years of feast, then complete collapse …
while the oil, coal, and timber companies are long gone, searching
for the next valley to plunder.’
Jacob Wheeler

Go there>>
Does the Great
White North Deserve Its Green Reputation?

Related Links:

Related Links from the Utne

Comments? Story tips?
Write a letter to the editor

Like this? Want more?Subscribe to Utne

In-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.