The Way of the Holy Fool

At the crossroads this year, after
begging all day
I lingered at the village temple.
Children gather round me and
whisper,
‘The crazy monk has come back
to play.’
–Taigu Ryokan

Taigu Ryokan lives on as one of Japan’s best-loved poets, the
wise fool who wrote of his humble life with directness. Born in
1758, he is part of a tradition of radical Zen poets, or ‘great
fools,’ that includes China’s Han-shan and P’ang Yun (Layman P’ang)
and Japan’s Ikkyu Sojun and Hakuin Ekaku.

The eldest of seven children, Ryokan grew up near Mount Kugami
in the town of Izumozaki, a community for artists and writers. His
father, a scholar of Japanese literature and a renowned haiku poet,
was the town’s ineffectual mayor. His mother was a quiet woman who
eventually had to deal with her husband’s abandoning his position
and his family and then drowning himself in the river Katsura.

In his youth, Ryokan trained under a Confucian scholar and began
to study Chinese literature in the original. At 16, he had already
flirted with a life of gambling and women, then surprised everyone
by taking up the study of Soto Zen at the nearby Koshoji temple.
(Soto and Rinzai comprise the two main schools of Japanese Zen
Buddhism.) He shaved his head and took his robes and vows. At 21,
he moved to the Entsuji temple in Bitchu, but eventually became
disillusioned and outraged at the corrupt practices of vain and
greedy temple priests and left to make his mountain hermitage.

Ryokan had no disciples and ran no temple; in the eyes of the
world he was a penniless monk who spent his life in the snow
country of Mount Kugami. He admired most of the teachings of Dogen,
the 13th century monk who first brought Soto Zen to Japan. He was
also drawn to the unconventional life and poetry of the Zen
mountain poet Han-shan, who lived in China sometime during the
T’ang Dynasty (618 to 907). He repeatedly refused to be honored or
confined as a ‘professional,’ either as a Buddhist priest or as a
poet. He wrote:

Who says my poems are poems?
These poems are not poems.
When you can understand this,
then we can begin to speak of poetry.

Ryokan never published a collection of verse while he was alive.
His practice consisted of sitting in zazen meditation,
walking in the woods, playing with children, making his daily
begging rounds, reading and writing poetry, doing calligraphy, and
on occasion drinking wine with friends.

Ryokan later dubbed himself Taigu, or ‘Great Fool,’ but
this title had a special meaning. A Zen master who taught the young
Ryokan described him this way: ‘Ryokan looks like a fool, but his
way of life is an entirely emancipated one. He lives on playing, so
to say, with his destiny, liberating himself from every kind of
fetter.’ He went on to describe his disciple’s simple life: ‘In the
morning he wanders out of his hut and goes God knows where and in
the evening loiters around somewhere. For fame he cares nothing.
Men’s cunning ways he puts out of the question.’ His freewheeling
spirit had much in common with the American writer Henry David
Thoreau’s. Ryokan’s life was an affirmation of alternate values and
a rebuke to the hypocrisy and rigid values found in Japanese Zen
monasteries and in society at large.

His ‘foolishness’ belongs in a Taoist-Buddhist context as an
inversion of social norms. Ryokan declares the Way of the Fool in
his poem ‘No Mind’:

With no mind, flowers lure the
butterfly;
With no mind, the butterfly visits
the blossoms.
Yet when flowers bloom, the butterfly
comes;
When the butterfly comes, the
flowers bloom
.

‘No mind,’ or mushin, means not to cling or to strive,
and when it is joined with mujo, or acceptance of life’s
impermanence, we have the greatness of the fool.

To achieve this original or beginner’s mind, Ryokan sought the
company of children, kept his humble begging rounds, accepted his
everyday life, and recorded it all in his authentic poems. Dropping
whatever he was doing, he would turn to join the children’s games
of tag and blindman’s buff, hide-and-seek, and ‘grass fights.’ He
was once caught playing marbles with a geisha and is said never to
have refused a game of Go. He relished playing dead for the
children, who would bury him in leaves, and he would spend the day
picking flowers with them, forgetting his begging rounds.

The stories of Ryokan’s playfulness are legendary. Here’s one,
preserved after his death in 1831 in Ryokan’s family archive:

‘Ryokan was playing hide-and-seek, and when it came his turn to
hide, he looked around for a spot where the children wouldn’t find
him. Noticing a tall haystack, he crawled inside, concealing
himself completely in the hay. No matter how hard they searched,
the children couldn’t find him. Soon they grew tired of playing,
the sun began to set, and when they saw the smoke rising from the
dinner fires, they deserted Ryokan and returned to their homes.
Unaware of this, Ryokan imagined the children were still searching
for him. Thinking, ‘Here they come to look for me! Now they’re
going to find me,’ he waited and waited. He waited all night and
was still waiting when dawn arrived. In farmhouses, in the morning
the kitchen hearth is lit by burning bundles of hay, and when the
farmer’s daughter came to fetch some of these, she was startled to
find Ryokan hiding in the haystack. ‘Ryokan! What in the world are
you doing here?’ she cried. ‘Shh!’ Ryokan warned her, ‘The children
will find me.’ ‘

His tendency to misplace things–his walking stick, his begging
bowl, books, even his underwear–was well known. Among the stories
of his chronic forgetfulness is one of a visit by the famous
scholar Kameda Bosai. When Bosai found Ryokan sitting zazen
on the porch of his hut, he waited–several hours–for the monk to
finish, and then Bosai and Ryokan happily talked poetry,
philosophy, and writing until evening, when Ryokan rose to fetch
them some sake from town.

Again Bosai waited several hours, then grew concerned and began
to walk toward the village. When he found his host a hundred yards
away, sitting under a pine tree, he exclaimed, ‘Ryokan! Where have
you been? I’ve been waiting for hours and was afraid something had
happened to you.’ Ryokan looked up. ‘Bosai, you have just come in
time. Look, isn’t the moon splendid tonight?’ When Bosai asked
about the sake, Ryokan replied, ‘Oh, yes, the sake. I
forgot all about it,’ and headed off to town. To be distracted by
life’s moments is indeed a Zen virtue, though it is often a trial
for friends.

Ryokan often wrote in the Kanshi form–poems composed in
classical Chinese. Taken together, his Kanshi poems are best
seen as an undated journal, a record of a humble life spent living
in the moment without thoughts of fame and power. In recording his
experience of play, begging, observing people and nature, and
accepting life’s bounty, Ryokan becomes the self-deprecating great
fool in order to mentor us in an authentic life of simplicity,
trust, humility, and finding the true way in everyday life.

Larry Smith is a professor of English
and humanities at Bowling Green State University in Ohio. He is
currently working with Mei Hui of Taiwan on a translation of poems
by Ryokan entitled
Kanshi Poems by Ryokan. From the
spiritual journal
Parabola(Fall 2001). Subscriptions: $24/yr
(4 issues.) From Box 3000, Denville, NJ 07834.

UTNE
UTNE
In-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.