Capturing the Elusive Echo of Why

Seeking meaning in life after decades of alcoholism and apparently random tragedy.

| Summer 2017

  • Current state of the Superconducting Super Collider site in Waxahachie, Texas. This is a view of the Magnet Development Laboratory building, with other buildings visible in the background.
    Photo courtesy Wikimedia Commons/bomazi
  • The intangibility and omnipresence of God in Alcoholics Anonymous' twelve-step program raises questions of how completely we can know the universe.
    Photo by Flickr/wwward0
  • As we seek an answer to The Big Question, we continually find that more is unknown than is known.
    Photo by Flickr/jurvetson

The world of the happy man is a different one from that of the unhappy man. — Wittgenstein, Tractatus 6.43

In an alternate world, the Superconducting Super Collider would have been housed in a squat gray block in Waxahachie, Texas, but instead the overbudget and behind-schedule dream of it died in the fall of 1993. Beneath the building, there still lie the unfinished tunnels — which eventually would have spanned a 54-mile ellipse — around which protons would have raced through massive magnets at high energies and crashed together over and over and over again, the ghostly aftereffects of their collisions revealing glimpses of the unseeable.

Had the SSC been built, the United States may well have been host to the discovery of the Higgs boson — also known as the God Particle — a discovery that would perhaps have happened even sooner than the announcement in 2012 by the European Organization for Nuclear Research, or CERN, that earned Peter Higgs the Nobel.

The history of the SSC, the world’s most expensive and advanced physics experiment that never was, is interesting and complicated but I’m going to boil it down for now to this: Republicans in Congress viewed spending money on smashing elementary particles together to gain new knowledge about the universe and everything in it as extravagant. As Representative Sherwood Boehlert (R-NY) said in 1993, “I doubt anyone believes that the most pressing issues facing the nation include an insufficient understanding of the origins of the universe.”

For nearly 20 years thereafter, the husk of the abandoned SSC sat outside Waxahachie, accumulating graffiti and used only for “alcohol and drug parties,” by one account. The SSC would have been bigger and more ambitious than the Large Hadron Collider built by CERN. By far. The possibility of discovery that the SSC project represented became instead a sign of decline: the U.S. would not lead the world in this scientific arena; Waxahachie would not be the site of this historic undertaking, but would spend two decades waiting for someone to occupy the building. (In 2012, around the time the Higgs was being announced by CERN, a local chemical company named Magnablend bought the SSC. They kept the acronym, calling the facility their Specialty Services Complex, renovated it, and put it to use — despite public fears and a 2015 chemical leak that resulted in an explosion and evacuation — so in this way, the building remained a place in which substances are changed into other substances.)

The AA meeting I went to was not in Waxahachie but farther east, in a low, lonely building with corrugated metal siding and a conspicuous sign. The wood-paneled, linoleum-lined room with its folding tables and chairs recalled the upstairs of the fire station in the town where I grew up, which was where I attended Boy Scouts meetings for a couple years. On one of the first evenings I attended AA, the topic was, approximately, “What the 12th Step Means to You.” The 12th step is about carrying AA’s message to the alcoholic who still suffers after one has had “a spiritual awakening as the result of these Steps.” When it came my turn to speak — it was a small group and, barring verbalized abstention, everyone spoke — I tried to go honestly at the heart of the thing I had been struggling with about AA. I named myself, confessed or diagnosed I was an alcoholic, and admitted I’d only been coming to meetings for a week or so. Thus, I had nothing to say about the 12th step, but what I was looking at and really resisting was the underlying premise most explicitly stated in Step 3, “Made a decision to turn our will and our lives over to the care of God as we understood Him.”

6/18/2018 11:32:49 AM

Brilliant! Thank you!

6/18/2018 11:32:30 AM

Brilliant! Thank you!

12/30/2017 8:02:39 PM

It can be difficult to get past Step 3. I think that's what killed my brother, along with being unable to face what he had done to his wife and daughters. Traditional activities like reading the Lord's Prayer after meetings might not be as helpful here to people who cannot immediately distinguish between traditional activities and the core meaning of the program. The founders of A.A. were Episcopalian Christian, and this holds over in much of the writing, much of which is quite old at this point. Lots of people are successfully sober in A.A. without the Christian tradition; atheists, agnostics, Buddhists, Native Americans. One thought I have had which helps me is that religion is what other people tell me about God; spirituality is what I find out for myself, that feels right about a power greater than myself. Spirituality is what lets me get through the day without feeling like I can't do it without getting drunk or stoned. One part toward the end of the book Alcoholics Anonymous (Appendix II Spiritual Experience) is: "Willingness, honesty and open mindedness are the essentials of recovery. But these are indispensable." Somehow I have been able to make these my core operating principles, along with a commitment to living a decent life that helps other people with some kind of a positive-ish attitude. I'm still fearful, anxious, lonely, irritable, impatient and judgmental, but I'm getting better. After about 25 years since my first meeting (and over 19 years continuously clean and sober) I'm still having really major realizations about this stuff on a regular basis. Where would we be now if we'd built the SSC? How many generations of physicists, mathematicians, technicians, manufacturers, and skilled workers would we have produced? Hal.

Facebook Instagram Twitter