The Environmental Cost of a Free Canvas Bag

When it comes to the environment, free canvas bags aren’t free
by Dmitri Siegel, from Creative Review
September-October, 2009
Add to My MSN

image designed by Genevieve Guackler / www.partofit.org


Content Tools

Related Content

One Million Acts of Green

The Canadian Broadcasting Corporation has launched “One Million Acts of Green,” a campaign to mobili...

A Givebox on Every Corner

An anonymous do-gooder in Berlin transforms a city-street eyesore (and improvised public toilet) by ...

Don’t Worry, Have a Hot Dog

It's tempting to succumb to liberal guilt when “everything from melting ice caps to parched cropland...

America’s Paper Trail

Paper Elephant outlines how prevalent paper is in our daily lives and how we can eliminate our obsce...

It’s difficult  to pinpoint when the canvas tote craze really started. The concept isn’t new, of course. Public television stations have been giving them away during fundraisers for decades, and L.L. Bean’s “Boat and Tote” has been a New England staple even longer. Sometime during the past few years, how­ever, the environmental appeal of reusable bags and the easy application of graphics catapulted canvas sacks from health food stores to the runway.

Graphic designers embraced the form as a venue for messages on a par with the T-shirt. Design blogs became enthralled by the never-ending stream of totes—each one made unique by a clever or beautiful graphic. This glut of bags raises questions about the sustainability of any product regardless of the intentions behind it.

The ascension of canvas, after all, was fueled by the totes’ compelling social benefits. Not only is canvas a renewable resource, but the bags are biodegradable and sturdy enough to stand up to years of use. With global warming emerging as an everyday anxiety, designers and consumers alike latched on to the reusable tote as a tangible step they could take to help the environment. Reusing canvas bags could reduce—and eventually eliminate—the billions of plastic bags that are discarded every year.

The thought is noble, but it’s worth considering the irony: The plastic bag itself began as an environmental salve. Before the introduction of ultra-thin plastic bags in the 1980s, groceries were primarily packed in paper. Plastic was touted as a way to save trees. Within a few years plastic dominated the market. Comparing plastic to paper, it’s easy to see why; the plastic bag is a vastly superior design. It consumes 40 to 70 percent less energy to manufacture, generates 80 percent less solid waste, and produces 60 percent fewer atmospheric emissions. A plastic bag costs a quarter as much to produce and is substantially lighter (so it takes far less fuel to transport).

What is marvelous about an individual bag, however, becomes menacing when it is multiplied to accommodate a global economy. The low cost allowed merchants to give plastic bags away and, despite their strength, they’re routinely double-bagged. Their incredible durability means it can take up to hundreds of years for them to decompose. Although plastic bags are recyclable, in-store programs have barely managed to achieve a 1 percent recycle rate. It is simply too easy and efficient to keep making and distributing more plastic bags.

We could be headed for the same kind of catch-22 with the adoption of the canvas tote. I’m certainly an outlier in this case, but I recently found 23 of them in my house. Most were given to me as promotional materials for design studios, start-ups, and boutique shops; more than one came from an environmental organization; one even commemorates a friend’s wedding. A community group recently delivered a reusable bag to every house in my neighborhood to promote local holiday shopping.

This zeal for reusable bags is inspiring, but it also reveals the fundamental contradiction of the canvas tote phenomenon. Once this gorgeous flat surface presented itself, it quickly became a substrate for messaging, branding, and promotion—and the emphasis shifted from reusing a bag to having one that reflects status or personality.

Judging by the cost, producing one tote is equivalent to producing 400 plastic bags. That’s fine if you use a tote 400 times, but what if you just end up with 40 totes? The environmental promise of reusable bags becomes dubious when there are closets full of them in every home.

Designers are correct in thinking that making a more appealing bag increases the likelihood that it will be reused, but environmental benefit doesn’t come from people acquiring bags. It comes from people reusing them. Successful attempts to reduce the number of plastic bags have all focused (unsurprisingly) on depressing their consumption. In 2001 Ireland consumed 1.2 billion plastic bags, 316 per person. In 2002 the country introduced a PlasTax—at the time 15 eurocents for every plastic bag consumed. The program reduced consumption of plastic bags by 90 percent. This success seems to undercut the strategy of selling reusable totes as a way to help the environment.

In terms of actually reducing the number of plastic bags floating around in our world, programs like the one at U.S. Ikea stores (customers pay five cents per bag and the proceeds go a conservation group) are more likely to have an impact than selling a canvas alternative. The best thing for the environment is reuse—and that can be accomplished just as easily by reusing plastic bags.

This isn’t to trash canvas: The aesthetic power of a single design raised more awareness about the impact of plastic bags on our environment than any government or nongovernment organization. Every well-designed tote had the potential to replace some of the estimated 1,000 plastic bags that each family brings home every year. It is simply unclear if a consumable can ever counteract the effects of consumption. The designs that make each bag unique contribute to an overabundance of things that are essentially identical, while the stream of newness, in the end, discourages reuse. Best intentions are buried under an avalanche of conspicuous consumption.

Just as the remarkable efficiency of the plastic bag transformed a solution into a menace, consumer culture could turn reusable canvas bags into an environmental calamity.

 

Dmitri Siegel (www.dmitrisiegel.com) is a Philadelphia-based designer and writer. This essay first appeared on DesignObserver.com. We spotted it republished in Creative Review (April 2009), a British magazine that covers all aspects of visual communication. www.creativereview.co.uk


Previous | 1 | 2 | Next






Post a comment below.

 

Susan K. Stewart
10/7/2009 9:06:47 AM
Can we do anything right? First, we switched to plastic to save trees. Now, we're told paper bags are better than plastic. Re-usable bags became the ticket. Now, you're telling us they're not environmentally sound. I get my canvas bags at yard sales & thrift shops. Some of them I've used for more than 10 years. I'm not about to count individual uses. The fact is any bag is reusable -- plastic, paper, or kumquat. Consumers just need to be educated -- look at the number of news bags being used at the grocery store. People haven't gotten the point yet. Articles like this one defeats attempts to educated about reuse. Hmmm ... why bother if it's all bad. Another point of education is simplify. I buy my produce from a local farmers coop. No bag needed. I buy staples by bulk through another coop. Don't use a bag. I only have to go to the grocery store once a month a most. And, I proudly take my reusable bags.

Brucecohen_1
10/5/2009 11:13:07 PM
The way to use canvas bags is to have them barcoded by the supermarket, use the same ones each time and get discount or gas miles or other incentive when used. This helps cut down multiple production of canvas bags. Other methods in the same vein: 1- promote a favorite charity by having the supermarket donate in your name from the same bar-coded bag. might be tax deduction as well. 2. promote a cause. Print bags with slogan, ie; "eliminate plastic bags" 3. since most folks shop at the same market each time, the reusable bag can be tracked and info used for a variety of purposes. 4. When no longer useful, canvas bags can be recycled for making paper.

Summer Hirschi
9/10/2009 4:35:12 PM
I had a conversation with my neighbor just yesterday about the stockpile of the new non-woven polyethylene grocery bags I'm amassing. They're great--easier to carry home when one is on foot--but I agree with this article. They're one more thing for me to buy and I am buying them. Dozens of them. They, unlike the canvas bags, are still made from a petroleum product, and they don't last as long. Good things to think about, thanks!








Pay Now & Save $5!
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Address: *
City: *
State/Province: *
Zip/Postal Code:*
Country:
Email:*
(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here

Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our earth-friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $5 and get 4 issues of Utne Reader for only $31.00 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $36 for 4 issues of Utne Reader!