November 20, 2009
UTNE READER

Simple Living for the Environment Is for Suckers

Simple Living Sucks
image by Jesse Kuhn / www.rawtoastdesign.com
Article Tools
Bookmark and Share

Hey, all you guilt-stricken liberals. Let the water run. Throw those recyclable milk jugs in the trash. And drive that 15-year-old gas-guzzling truck all over town. Heck, flip off a bicyclist while you’re at it.

RELATED CONTENT

Not interested? Fine. Go ahead and eschew these eco-heretical lifestyle choices; just don’t go feeling high and mighty about it.

That’s the takeaway from a biting essay in Orion (July-Aug. 2009), written by the always provocative Derrick Jensen. Railing against “simple living as a political act,” the radical environmentalist argues that focusing on our personal choices as a salve for eco-destruction is not only misguided, but also ineffective.

“Would any sane person think Dumpster diving would have stopped Hitler, or that composting would have ended slavery or brought about the eight-hour workday . . . or that dancing naked around a fire would have helped put in place the voting rights act of 1957 or the Civil Rights Act of 1964? Then why now, with all the world at stake, do so many people retreat into these entirely personal ‘solutions’?”

To prop up his provocative prose, Jensen shows how agriculture and industry are responsible for the bulk of water and energy use, as well as the majority of emissions and waste. This is a reality that’s often overlooked on those ubiquitous “how to be green” lists, which include recommendations for individuals: shorter showers, lighter dishwasher settings, canvas bags for the grocery store.

It’s fine, Jensen says, if you live simply just because you want to. But to pretend that doing so is “a powerful political act” distracts citizens from confronting the larger consequences of an environmentally destructive industrial economy. It also prevents people from becoming true stewards of the earth, relying instead on “the flawed notion that humans inevitably harm their landbase.”

“Simple living as a political act consists solely of harm reduction, ignoring the fact that humans can help the earth as well as harm it,” Jensen writes. “We can rehabilitate streams, we can get rid of noxious invasives, we can remove dams, we can disrupt a political system tilted toward the rich as well as an extractive economic system, we can destroy the industrial economy that is destroying the real, physical world.”

Comments

  • Rock 11/18/2009 11:46:46 AM

    You need more than one arrow in your quiver, more than one color on your palette. You need to conceptualize on both the personal and the global level. You need to understand at the gut level what you are promoting. It isn't buying organic veggies at the supermarket that were trucked across the nation (I'm in the east), it's growing them in your backyard. It's growing/buying when fruits and vegetables are in season and excess and preserving them. It's changing your lifestyle to be more self sufficient, and not falling into the distribution channel myth that they will provide all you need - what you need to do is work at a useless job earning money to buy their "stuff". Homemaking use to be an honorable task. But, yes, we need money or else Susie and Jimmy can't have their own cell phone, and how will we get 200 ridiculous channels on cable, and game boy, wii, etc. The localvore idea is good - short distribution areas based on 40-50 mile radius is a great start. I keep thinking Americans will wake up to food safety (Jensen id's ag as one of the two main culprits) with the next e coli scare, but they keep coming, and people keep trusting Big Ag to keep them fat and happy. Find a CSA, start an urban garden with your neighbors, do something that creates 'wealth', ie, convert human effort and renewable natural resources into useful products. How many families can eat off one vacant urban lot? (I'll shut up now.)

  • daltxguy 11/17/2009 6:51:08 PM

    I live 'green' because I am cheap, not because of a political act. I don't want to pay high fuel bills, electric bills, mortgages. I don't want to feed the corporatocracy by being a consumer.

    The single most mind blowing event leading to the current depression is that middle Americans chose to 'walk away' from their mortgages because when the value of their homes dropped below their mortgages. This is not possible anywhere else in the world, btw but look at the effect that this has had! Now, the govt response of course was to reward banks for their stupidity, not to recognize the power of the individuals who said f-you to the banks.

    The point is, though, that individual action can bring down large corporations, which is what it is going to take before anything changes.

    Americans are not yet outraged enough to realize that govt has been taken over and is no longer 'by the people, for the people'. When that happens and people take to the streets,
    true change can begin to occur.

  • Lisa Bernstein 11/17/2009 3:11:42 PM

    The point is, simple living can be part of a larger political stance. Of course we urgently need a change in our industries. We have for years and years.
    Canvas bags in the grocery store help people wake up and get interested in realizing that we need some changes.
    As does riding a bicycle and buying less crap to put in a landfill.
    Of course we need to write letters, vote for leaders who will take sensible action, and head in sustainable direction. Voting with are pocketbooks and making visable choices in our lives are part of that.

  • Jennifer Caputo 11/17/2009 2:30:56 PM

    Wow! What a dangerous idea to spread - that the individual can't make a difference. Small changes don't fix everything at once, so don't bother. As if people don't feel helpless and disenfranchised enough! It takes millions of drops of water to fill a reservoir, but no matter how big the quantity needed, it is still made up of drops. How many drops have you wasted today?

  • Keryl McCord 11/17/2009 12:02:56 PM

    Well, this was an eye-opener. What a thought provoking and powerful piece. However, having said that, and fully agreeing with his overall premise, it is still critical that as individuals we do what we can not to waste resources, not to continue to use plastics and other items that will outlast us. That's just common sense.

    Jansen is correct when he says that it was only through an all out commitment to confront the system and status quo that change occurred. But change also had to occur at the personal level. The personal is political was trite and true, as is all politics is local. We have to learn to live our principles, and to fight for them as well.

Add Your Comment

We’d like to know what you think. To comment, please use this form. E-mail addresses are never displayed on comments, but they are required to confirm your comments. First time registrants: You will receive an email confirming your email address. Once you confirm, your comment will be posted. Questions about our comments policy? Click here.

Line breaks and paragraphs are automatically converted — no need to use <p> or <br> tags.

New to Utne Reader?
Sign up to share comments.
Asterisks(*) indicate required fields.
Name*
Your name appears next to your comment.

E-mail Address*
This will be your login ID.

City State Zip Code

Password*


Confirm Password*

Comments
1500 character limit (Offensive materials and/or spam will be removed, no HTML allowed)
Please Note: Your sign-up must be verified via e-mail before your comment is published.


Pay Now & Save $6!
First Name: *
Last Name: *
Address: *
City: *
State/Province: *
Zip/Postal Code:*
Country:
Email:*
(* indicates a required item)
Canadian subs: 1 year, (includes postage & GST). Foreign subs: 1 year, . U.S. funds.
Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Non US and Canadian Subscribers - Click Here
Want to gain a fresh perspective? Read stories that matter? Feel optimistic about the future? It's all here! Utne Reader offers provocative writing from diverse perspectives, insightful analysis of art and media, down-to-earth news and in-depth coverage of eye-opening issues that affect your life.

Save Even More Money By Paying NOW!

Pay now with a credit card and take advantage of our Earth-Friendly automatic renewal savings plan. You save an additional $6 and get 6 issues of Utne Reader for only $29.95 (USA only).

Or Bill Me Later and pay just $36 for 6 issues of Utne Reader!